SERIOUS BUYERS OF SERIOUS COINS — SINCE 1946
Long Island's Trusted Coin Dealers
We buy gold & silver coins, PCGS/NGC graded coins, rare U.S. coinage, bullion, and entire estate collections — with expert appraisals and cash offers on the spot.
Let's Get Started
Expert Coin Appraisals in Lynbrook
Welcome to Collectors Coins & Jewelry
At Collectors Coins & Jewelry in Lynbrook, we pride ourselves on our expertise in evaluating both U.S. and foreign coins.
With 70+ years of experience, our team is dedicated to providing accurate and fair appraisals, ensuring that collectors and sellers receive the best possible value for their coins. Whether you’re looking to sell a single rare coin or an entire collection, our knowledgeable staff is here to assist you every step of the way, making sure you are given peace of mind.
How Selling Your Coins Works
1. Bring them in — or text a photo first
No appointment needed. Walk into our Lynbrook store, or text photos for a preliminary read on larger collections.
2. Expert evaluation, in front of you
Our numismatists assess date, mint mark, grade and market demand piece by piece — nothing leaves your sight.
3. Firm cash offer, no obligation
Take our offer on the spot and walk out with cash, or take time to decide. The appraisal is free either way.
Coins We're Actively Buying
Gold Coins
American Gold Eagles & Buffalos, Krugerrands, Canadian Maple Leafs, pre-1933 U.S. gold ($2.50, $5, $10, $20 Liberty & Saint-Gaudens), and world gold coinage.
Silver Dollars & 90% Silver
Morgan and Peace dollars, American Silver Eagles, and pre-1965 “junk silver” dimes, quarters & halves — by the piece or by the bag.
Graded & Certified Coins
PCGS, NGC, ANACS and CAC-stickered coins. Bring your slabs — we pay real numismatic value, not melt.
Rare & Key-Date U.S. Coins
Key dates, better dates, and low-mintage issues across all U.S. series, from half cents to double eagles.
Bullion & Proof Sets
Gold, silver, platinum & palladium bullion in any form, plus U.S. Mint proof and mint sets.
Estate & Inherited Collections
Inherited a collection and not sure what you have? We evaluate entire estates — albums, folders, safe deposit boxes — and explain what everything is worth, free of charge.
Coin Selling FAQ
Do I need an appointment to sell my coins?
No appointment is needed. Stop by during business hours and we’ll take a look at your coins while you’re here.
Do you buy graded coins in PCGS or NGC holders?
I inherited a coin collection and have no idea what's in it. Can you help?
Are my old pennies valuable?
How do you pay?
Explore Our Coin Collection
Rare and Collectible Coins Gallery
A Quick Word About Pocket Change
We love coins — but honesty is part of our reputation. Most modern coins found in circulation (pennies, nickels, dimes and quarters from recent decades) are worth face value, despite what viral videos suggest. If that’s what you have, we’ll tell you straight — but a trip may not be worth your time.
Where we can genuinely pay you well: silver coins dated 1964 and earlier, gold coins of any date, graded coins, and older collections. Not sure which you have? Text us a photo at (646) 450-1068 and we’ll tell you before you drive over.